This electric metal gem is up 55% in 2018 and investors have hardly noticed
March 19, 2018
- At $14.2/lb, vanadium pentoxide’s price is up 55% in 2108 and up 280% from the 2017 low of $5/lb
- Vanadium is used in both the cathodes and the anodes of utility grid scale flow batteries that supercharge wind and solar farms
- The global vanadium supply, which is mostly Chinese, will be limited in coming years due to Chinese environmental restrictions
- With a low global inventory and growing demand, vanadium prices are likely to be propelled higher than the current eight-year high
- Besides buying the vanadium metal, another way to invest in vanadium is through buying shares of vanadium mining companies
After the Bank of Montreal’s star analyst published bullish research notes on vanadium in January (2018), the price of vanadium pentoxide (v2o5) went up another 55%. That made it the best-performing electric metal, surpassing cobalt and lithium by a wide margin.
Vanadium Pentoxide Prices
2018 gain: approx. 55%
Gain since 2017: approx. 280%
Cobalt Price Chart
2018 gain: approx. 22%
Gain since 2017: approx. 250%
US$88,000 per tonne = US$40/lb
Lithium Carbonate Price
2018 gain: flat
Gain since 2017: 30%
Vanadium is used in redox flow batteries, which are superior to lithium batteries in storage capacity, discharge duration, and battery life. I have written extensively about this.
Vanadium articles by John Lee
Ride The Vanadium Wave After Lithium Dec 2016
Vanadium and lithium are comparable in unit price and annual production.
As for cobalt, the price is now $88,000/tonne, with an annual production of 110,000 tonnes ($9.7 billion).
1 vanadium = 1.79 vanadium pentoxide
The following January BMO note is as relevant today as it was in January.
“We see a situation where over the coming months Chinese exports of ferrovanadium could drop sharply on the back of increased domestic demand and raw material constraints.
Chinese vanadium supply is also under pressure. As with many other commodities, China's vanadium mine supply has already been impacted by more stringent environmental monitoring. Moreover, as of January 1 this year imports of vanadium slag have been banned, cutting ~6% of China's raw material supply.”
According to following notes by Metal Bulletin on March 14, the European and US vanadium markets surged on significant supply concerns:
“Major domestic V2O5 producers reported no cargoes to sell in spot market, and ferro-vanadium producers raised prices and are selling in small amounts.
Metal Bulletin has learned that major V2O5 producers including Tranvic Group, Jianlong Group and Desheng Group are fulfilling long-term orders and claimed to have no stock to sell into spot market.
There were very few export offers for V2O5 last week, with only one source concluding a deal for two containers of the material at $14.60 per Ib.”
Persistent demand, restrained supply, and limited available inventory could drive vanadium prices further upwards well beyond the current eight-year high of $14.2/lb
While lithium and cobalt mining stocks have been benefiting from an investor frenzy, the valuation of vanadium mining companies has been laggard.
The stock chart of First Cobalt Corp, a Cobalt mineral exploration company.
The stock chart of Prophecy Development Corp, a vanadium mineral exploration company.
Prophecy (TSX: PCY, OTCQX: PRPCF), of which I am the executive chairman, is developing the Gibellini vanadium project in Nevada, USA. Gibellini has independently verified vanadium resources in the ground, and Prophecy aims to make Gibellnii the 1st vanadium mine in North America. My recent radio interview about Gibellini and the vanadium market can be heard here.
Anthony Milewski is a managing director at Pala Investments Ltd. in Switzerland. He runs one of the few funds investing in battery metals. He made these comments in a January 2018 Bloomberg interview:
“I don’t think anyone would dispute that it’s superior to lithium-ion in large-scale grid applications.”
The Chinese government is promoting the technology. Among the projects under construction is a backup power facility in Dalian. It will be twice the size of Tesla’s plant in Australia.
The industry also lacks a high-profile champion such as Elon Musk. “Vanadium flow has yet to have its Tesla moment, and therefore it still flies under the radar,” Milewski said.
To me, with vanadium making new eight-year highs daily, the vanadium story may soon be too compelling to ignore.
John Lee, CFA