Six mining companies that pass Craton Capital's shareholder-centric filter
From his perch in Johannesburg, Swiss-born Craton Capital Fund Advisor Markus Bachmann has been watching the metals price and cost cycles, and he has some good news. The days of mining company managements using shareholders to support their lifestyle may be nearing an end. He is seeing more companies run like a business, throwing off free cash flow even in a depressed price environment and providing opportunities to get in on the ground floor of turnaround stories. In this interview with The Gold Report, Bachmann shares six names from the portfolio that pass his rigorous resource and operational criteria tests.
The Gold Report: What are the indicators you watch when evaluating the fundamentals behind gold, silver and copper? Are you looking at financial policies in the U.S.? Gross domestic product (GDP) in China? Economic headlines from Europe? Something else entirely?
Markus Bachmann: Those are all short-term catalysts. A potential interest rate increase in the U.S. might be a midterm overhang, but it could also be a catalyst. We shouldn't overanalyze the gold market. The gold market will do what the gold market will do. It often comes down to a longer-term sentiment. We learned over the last few decades that gold moves in rather lengthy cycles.
One fallacy is that gold is a safe haven. During a financial crisis like the one in 2008, gold is often used as a source of liquidity of last resort. That's why when the world goes to pot, gold declines because it is being sold into a falling environment to fulfill margin calls or it is sold because other assets are falling even harder.
Distressed financial markets, as we saw when the Shanghai Composite declined and corrected significantly over a very short period of time, can put pressure on the gold price, too. We suspect a lot of gold was released into the market during what many thought would be a positive for the shiny metal. The reality is that gold was used as a collateral to buy equities by some of the Chinese investors.
All of these headline issues might have a short-term news impact or a midterm overhang, but overall, they don't move the needle. We don't know when the sentiment in favor of gold is going to turn, but it will. It may depend on where you sit. An investor in Sydney, Australia, probably sees gold's value in Aussie dollars completely differently because it had a great return over the past two years. Someone sitting in New York, Los Angeles or San Francisco will use a U.S. dollar measurement and had a negative return over the same time period.
Calling the market can be a fool's game. It's difficult to say that June/August was the bottom for gold after a four-year correction. We're a little cautious. We are convinced it is the last curtain call approach for a correction. Gold always has a few tricks up its sleeves, but I think we are probably close to 97% through. While we are waiting for the last act in the metals correction, investors should watch it very carefully and keep their powder dry. Companies are sweating costs out, capital expenditures are falling and a free cash flow cycle is emerging. If gold turns the corner it will trigger a strong recovery in equities. But to call the bottom in bullion I would like to see an increase to about $1,280/ounce ($1,280/oz) for the multiyear low to be confirmed.
Plus, the investing world became much more complex over the last few years with the introduction of algorithmic trading. That makes everything more challenging to try to understand the direction.
TGR: How does your understanding of the cyclical nature of commodities, including the cyclical nature of all-in costs for mining companies, impact your investing strategy?
MB: The high cost inflation we saw from 2003 to 2012 was a function of the biggest investment cycle of the past 200 years. That investment boom led to a lot of capital chasing a very limited pool of skills, labor, equipment and contractors in a neglected sector. The result was massive cost inflation and company excesses. Since the investment cycle peaked in 2012, costs have moved into a deflationary direction. Shareholders have forced companies into austerity mindsets. Capital investments are coming down dramatically. For the first time, shareholders could benefit. For years to come, we could enjoy good free cash flow generation. Even companies like Barrick Gold Corp. (ABX:TSX; ABX:NYSE), Newmont Mining Corp. (NEM:NYSE) and Goldcorp Inc. (G:TSX; GG:NYSE) have started to turn around. That cycle of declining costs has a lot of legs across the sector.
TGR: You are a Swiss-born fund adviser living in Africa. How does that impact your analysis?
MB: The Swiss aspect is that we might be a bit pedantic when it comes to numbers. We want to find the reasons behind a specific event. The African component is that we learn to improvise because often things do not work the way they should. That is great preparation for operating in commodity markets. Particularly in the gold space, you always have to expect the unexpected because there is no fixed rule book.
In Johannesburg, we are very close to the commodity complex. The city is actually built on gold and mining tailings. My children go to school with the children of owners of iron ore mining companies, suppliers, refiners and financiers. We live very tangibly with the ups and downs of the commodity cycle every time we go to a barbecue.
TGR: What do you consider to be countries with manageable risk?
MB: It's a tricky question because, again, there are fallacies. You would think that a First World country is a safe jurisdiction to operate in, but you have a lot of regulator risk in places like the United States. While you may not have people protesting at your factory gates, you might have lawyers harassing you, and legal bills and fines can be excessive. Mexico has its own different challenges. It's a very prospective mining domicile, but companies need to give the security aspect a high importance. That goes for places in Latin America, like Colombia, as well.
It might actually be easier to operate in a country perceived as a "challenging environment" because the political system is less stable and the infrastructure is underdeveloped. There are domiciles to avoid, places with hostile mining policies or a lack of rule of law. I would probably include South Africa in that category. But by and large, I think every domicile is workable with a few exceptions. If you show respect, work on relationships and stand your ground, you can be successful almost anywhere.
In particular, we like Canada. It has a clear regulatory environment, great infrastructure and a skilled workforce. To a large extent, that applies to Australia as well. China has suddenly started to make acquisitions in domiciles like Canada and Australia; that tells you a lot.
TGR: Can companies in Canada and Australia take advantage of the exchange rates to help cash flow and profitability?
MB: Most definitely, but these things can go both ways. Australian gold producers have definitely benefitted from a favorable exchange rate environment. African costs are often linked to the euro. That has also been favorable in comparison to the U.S. dollar over the past couple of years. Companies can take advantage, but the exchange rate is the wrong tool to bail you out when you do a bad job. It might be a bit of a tailwind, but first and foremost, you need to do a good job on the ground by being very cognizant of your cost structure.
TGR: How do you use that unique perspective to evaluate companies?
MB: We have very simple investment criteria. We consider companies that do not manage more than five different assets. We are of the view that even a very good management team is not able to efficiently manage more than that, particularly if the portfolio includes geographical diversification. Another criterion is that companies be run as proper businesses, not lifestyle projects for management. Management must align its interests with the interests of shareholders. We look for companies that are able to self-fund future growth with generated cash flows and just a little bit of outside funding. We look for companies that are able to extend their life of mines, usually through exploration. Companies have to be able to be successful in today's metals price environment and have a sound balance sheet, operating in the lowest quartile of the cost curve. That filter gives you a relatively limited number of companies to look at closer.
TGR: Let's talk about some of the specific companies in your portfolio.
MB: Endeavour Mining Corp. (EDV:TSX; EVR:ASX) is operating in various domiciles in West Africa. It grew relatively quickly through acquisitions. It's managed by a very savvy investment team that has cut operational costs quite significantly and may soon be expanding the resource with another project. It is now in a position to pay back debt and generate free cash flow. If Endeavour can continue to show this strength, the market may soon reward these types of companies with a premium or at least a rerating.
Kirkland Lake Gold Inc. (KGI:TSX) in Canada has been like a dog's breakfast for a long time and a cause of frustration for a lot of investors, like a lot of these companies have been. A new management team led by George Ogilvie came in and turned the company around. He is very diligent and focused. Running a mining operation is a lot of hard work, and the company did the right stuff. It was focusing on grades. It was focusing on implementing the right strategy. Now costs are coming down significantly and the company is generating cash flow for the first time in a while. Kirkland Lake is actually creating shareholder value. It's one of these high-grade operations, with relatively long life of mine and a lot of exploration potential, run by decent people. That's something we appreciate.
Another name that we like is Guyana Goldfields Inc. (GUY:TSX). It also has a relatively long life of mine. It's based in Guyana, which doesn't scare us off, despite the hapless picture painted by "The Gold Rush" series on National Geographic about an unprofessional crew working in the area. Guyana Goldfields will be in commercial production by the beginning of next year producing 200,000 oz (20 Koz). Guyana has a great cost structure and good life of mine that can be extended by going underground. I think it has the potential to create a lot of shareholder value.
Torex Gold Resources Inc. (TXG:TSX) operates in Mexico under an experienced and cautious management team that is well connected. President, CEO and Director Fred Stanford is doing a very good job bringing that project to production. We expect the first gold pour toward the end of this year, and it will go commercial next year. It has all-in sustaining costs of about US$650/oz normalized, about 355 Koz of annual production and life of mine of 10–12 years with prospectively the same for exploration success at El Limon and Media Luna, the next project. I think it's one of the more exciting new gold producers that actually will be on the market next year. It's a fascinating gold district with some challenges. Some banditos there can make your life miserable, but that can be dealt with.
Northern Star Resources Ltd. (NST:ASX) is a blueprint on how a 21st century gold producer should be managed. It has an excellent management team that took unloved, underexplored assets from big producers like Barrick and Newmont and turned them around. Now, Northern Star pays a dividend, has no debt and generates free cash flow. This success has been reflected in the share price of late, which is not in line with the market in general. Hopefully, the company doesn't get ahead of itself and continues that path.
MAG Silver Corp. (MAG:TSX; MVG:NYSE) is actually not in production yet, but it is a scarcity story because it's one of the best silver projects around. MAG Silver has a very strong joint venture partner and a lot of exploration upside. You can have an agnostic view on silver, and that company will do well. If you have a more constructive outlook on silver, that company has the potential to do very well. We like companies that have that special touch. MAG Silver is one of them.
TGR: You've talked about the importance of management teams that have interests aligned with shareholders. What's an example of someone who knows how to make projects work?
MB: We can give you a long list of examples of how it shouldn't be done. But one that is doing the right things is Brad Mills, founder of Plinian Capital, who runs an operationally competent and financially savvy team. His investment company is acquiring underutilized, unloved, underexplored and badly managed assets and turning them around. The company has avoided the huge correction that took place over the past few years. Most important, it is a substantial owner in the companies it takes an interest in and pays themselves dividends in line with all other shareholders instead of taking obscene salaries.
One of the companies in that portfolio is Mandalay Resources Corp. (MND:TSX). It is operating in Chile, Australia and Sweden. Mills serves as CEO and Director and fellow Plinian Capital Principal Sanjay Swarup is CFO and Director. Former PHP Vice President and Plinian Capital Principal Mark Sander is president there. It is paying a dividend and advancing projects. We like that.
Brad Mills is also an independent director at Helio Resource Corp. (HRC:TSX.V), which is a developer working next to Shanta Gold Ltd.'s (SHG:LSE) producing property. These are two small companies operating in Tanzania. Their assets are in very close proximity to each other. Common sense would tell you that it is nonsense to develop in the middle of nowhere a parallel infrastructure by two rather small companies. Hopefully, common sense will prevail, pride will be swallowed and they'll sit around the table and do the right thing in the long run to the benefit of shareholders.
TGR: What words of wisdom do you have for investors who are looking to adjust their portfolio to fit a changing resource world?
MB: Gold moves in big cycles. It is at the inflection points that you make the best returns. Right now, the gold industry is going through a significant change and costs—including long overinflated management costs—are coming down significantly. That will lay the foundation for much healthier companies with stronger balance sheets and lots of cash that, hopefully, will be distributed to shareholders.
TGR: Thank you for your time, Markus.
Mrkus Bachmann has advised the Craton Capital Precious Metal Fund since its inception in 2003 and has more than 18 years of experience managing/advising natural resources and related portfolios. Prior to cofounding Craton Capital in 2003, he held positions at Credit Suisse (corporate finance) and UBS (analyst and fund manager for SBC Brinson) in Zurich and Coronation Asset Management (senior PM and global resource specialist) in Cape Town, South Africa. Bachmann holds numerous awards for fund management.
Want to read more Gold Report interviews like this? Sign up for our free e-newsletter, and you'll learn when new articles have been published. To see a list of recent interviews with industry analysts and commentators, visit our Interviews page.
Source: JT Long of The Gold Report (11/5/15)
1) JT Long conducted this interview for Streetwise Reports LLC, publisher of The Gold Report, The Energy Report and The Life Sciences Report, and provides services to Streetwise Reports as an employee. She owns, or her family owns, shares of the following companies mentioned in this interview: None.
2) The following companies mentioned in the interview are sponsors of Streetwise Reports: MAG Silver Corp. and Guyana Goldfields Inc. Helio Resource Corp. is a banner sponsor of Streetwise Reports. Goldcorp Inc. is not affiliated with Streetwise Reports. The companies mentioned in this interview were not involved in any aspect of the interview preparation or post-interview editing so the expert could speak independently about the sector. Streetwise Reports does not accept stock in exchange for its services.
3) Markus Bachmann: I own, or my family owns, shares of the following companies mentioned in this interview: None. I personally am, or my family is, paid by the following companies mentioned in this interview: None. My company has a financial relationship with the following companies mentioned in this interview: None. My firm holds positions in all of the companies mentioned. I was not paid by Streetwise Reports for participating in this interview. Comments and opinions expressed are my own comments and opinions. I determined and had final say over which companies would be included in the interview based on my research, understanding of the sector and interview theme. I had the opportunity to review the interview for accuracy as of the date of the interview and am responsible for the content of the interview.
4) Interviews are edited for clarity. Streetwise Reports does not make editorial comments or change experts' statements without their consent.
6) From time to time, Streetwise Reports LLC and its directors, officers, employees or members of their families, as well as persons interviewed for articles and interviews on the site, may have a long or short position in securities mentioned. Directors, officers, employees or members of their families are prohibited from making purchases and/or sales of those securities in the open market or otherwise during the up-to-four-week interval from the time of the interview until after it publishes.
Streetwise – The Gold Report is Copyright © 2014 by Streetwise Reports LLC. All rights are reserved. Streetwise Reports LLC hereby grants an unrestricted license to use or disseminate this copyrighted material (i) only in whole (and always including this disclaimer), but (ii) never in part.
Streetwise Reports LLC does not guarantee the accuracy or thoroughness of the information reported.
Streetwise Reports LLC receives a fee from companies that are listed on the home page in the In This Issue section. Their sponsor pages may be considered advertising for the purposes of 18 U.S.C. 1734.