HUI Stocks vs. Gold
In this article we will have a look at the performance of the HUI index (Amex Gold Bugs) compared to the performance of Gold.
First of all, here is a composition of the HUI index:
Now here is a chart that plots the HUI index since January 1st 2000:
We can see that the HUI index had a very impressive run, from about $35 at the end of 2000 to about $635 last year.
That is a MUCH better performance that the SP500 index for example, which is now roughly at the same point as where it started about 12 years ago.
When we take a look at the medium term (5 years) for the HUI index, we can see that in 2008 it got flushed because of the liquidity crisis. Everything was being sold for cash, even the best quality assets. However, from the low of $150 in 2008, the HUI rallied more than 4-fold over the next 3.5 years, which is very impressive to say the least. In the autumn of 2010, the HUI broke out above the pink dotted line, and as we can see, it retested this level several times. If this line fails to hold, then the Fibonacci Retracement levels come in to play.
The performance of the HUI index seems to be very strong. But is it really that strong? Perhaps not.
Mining stocks are expected to provide some sort of leverage to the price of the underlying metals.
However, when we look at the following chart, which plots the HUI index divided by the price of Gold, we can see that the HUI index is not acting that strong at all. In fact, since April-May 2011 (remember that Silver set a top back then), the ratio of the HUI:Gold is falling, indicating that Gold outperforms the mining companies (or that the mining stocks underperform the price of Gold).
The ratio is now laying at an important Fibonacci Retracement level from the bottom in 2008 to the top in 2009. If this level breaks, the first support would lay at the green line (around 0.26), followed by the low of 2008.
That’s a bit scary, isn’t it?
Now let’s have a look at the medium term chart. We can see that the HUI:Gold ratio is showing signs of weakness, just like it did in 2008, right before the big crash:
However, this doesn’t necessarily mean that we are going to see a similar crash this time around, but a warned investor counts for 2.
Check out the chart below, which compares the Gold price since early 2011 until now to the Gold price in 2006 and beyond.
If the pattern holds, one would expect Gold to trade sideways for the remainder of the year, followed by a new sharp increase in price, which could take it up to $2,800 per ounce.
The interesting about it, is that the HUI is also acting similarly to 2006, as price has been trading sideways for over a year now:
Last but not least, below you can see a chart of Silver.
We can see that every time silver had a very sharp run up, it also came down sharply, which was then followed by a long period of price consolidation.
The last time the sharp increase occured was in late 2010 until May 2011, which was followed by a sharp drop (almost 50%) in price.
If the observation we made in Gold would be correct, this could mean that Silver might also trade sideways throughout the year (of course with ups and downs), followed by a new rally into the $75 area:
In another article (subscribers only) called “A Look At The 16 HUI Stocks“, I analyzed the performance of each component of the HUI index relative to the price of Gold and had a look at fundamental valuations (Price/Earnings, Price/Sales and Price/Book ratios). You can read a brief excerpt here:
Barrick Gold (ABX):
Barrick Gold, the world’s largest Gold producer, has underperformed Gold over the last 12 years as the following chart shows:
The ratio of ABX:$Gold is now near the 2008 low:
Barrick Gold is trading at only 7.5 times Forward Earnings, the lowest level since at least 1990 and pays a Dividend Yield of 1.30%:
ABX is trading at 3.22 times Sales, which is not far above the level reached in 2008:
ABX is trading at 1.80 times BookValue, and appears to bounce when trading at 1.4-1.60 times BookValue: